Enjoy Restaurants In Key West
Key West Restaurants
Key West Restaurants scene is as vibrant and eclectic as the island itself, offering a delectable journey for every palate. From charming, open-air eateries where roosters roam freely, to upscale waterfront establishments boasting breathtaking sunset views, the culinary landscape here is infused with a unique blend of Caribbean, Cuban, and fresh Floridian flavors. Whether you’re seeking the freshest seafood straight from the turquoise waters, authentic island comfort food, or a sophisticated fine-dining experience, Key West Restaurants invites you to savor its distinctive tastes in settings that are as memorable as the cuisine itself.
Editor’s Choice: Top Key West Restaurants
Embark on a captivating culinary journey in Key West, where vibrant flavors and unique atmospheres come alive! Our Key West Restaurants editors have hand-picked three stand-out restaurants for unforgettable dining experiences:
- Latitudes (on Sunset Key): For a truly enchanting escape, take a complimentary ferry to Latitudes on Sunset Key. Here, exquisite, seasonally-inspired cuisine is perfectly paired with breathtaking ocean views and spectacular sunsets—ideal for romance or a special occasion.
- Blue Heaven: If you crave authentic island charm, Blue Heaven offers a whimsical al fresco setting with roaming chickens and cats. Savor their legendary Key Lime Pie and Caribbean-American delights that capture the true spirit of Key West.
- Santiago’s Bodega: For a lively, social dining experience, Santiago’s Bodega invites you to savor a vibrant array of Spanish-inspired tapas. Their small plates are perfect for sharing and exploring an exciting medley of flavors.
These Top Key West Restaurants represent the best of Key West’s diverse and delectable dining scene, promising to tantalize your taste buds and create lasting memories.
245 Front St
Key West, FL 33040 (Sunset Key Cottages)
(305) 292-5394
Latitudes
For an unparalleled dining experience in Key West, Latitudes on Sunset Key offers an idyllic escape that perfectly blends fine dining with breathtaking natural beauty. Just a short, complimentary ferry ride across the water, this exquisite restaurant provides a truly romantic and luxurious setting, renowned for its oceanfront tables and spectacular sunset views. The menu focuses on seasonal, locally sourced ingredients, transforming them into elegant American-Caribbean cuisine that delights the senses, from fresh seafood to prime cuts. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply seeking an unforgettable meal in a serene, upscale environment, Latitudes promises an evening of culinary excellence set against one of the most stunning backdrops in the Florida Keys.
729 Thomas St
Key West, FL 33040
(305) 296-8666
Blue Heaven
Blue Heaven in Key West offers an undeniably unique dining experience, celebrated for its whimsical outdoor setting where chickens and cats freely roam, all beneath the shade of a majestic kapok tree. This historic spot, once a bordello and cockfighting ring, now serves up delicious Caribbean-American cuisine for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. You can savor their legendary towering Key Lime Pie, famous for its meringue, or enjoy the flavorful Lobster “BLT” Benedict at breakfast and Jamaican Jerk Chicken for dinner, all while soaking in the lively atmosphere and often enjoying live music. It’s a truly authentic Key West institution, though be prepared for a wait, especially for breakfast, as dinner reservations are recommended.
7305, 207 Petronia St #101, Key West, FL 33040
(305) 296-7691
Santiago’s Bodega
Nestled slightly off the main bustle of Duval Street, Santiago’s Bodega brings a vibrant taste of global-inspired tapas to Key West, making it a favorite for both locals and visitors seeking a dynamic dining experience. This charming restaurant embraces a cozy, eclectic atmosphere with warm lighting and colorful art, creating an inviting space perfect for shared plates and lively conversation. Their extensive menu features an array of small, exquisitely crafted dishes ranging from the famous spinach and goat cheese salad to succulent beef tenderloin with blue cheese butter, ensuring there’s something to tantalize every palate. Don’t miss their highly praised sangria, the ideal complement to an evening of culinary adventure in this beloved Key West gem.
600 Fleming St
Key West, FL 33040.
(305) 292-1244.
Cafe Marquesa
Nestled within the charming Marquesa Hotel, Café Marquesa stands as a beacon of refined dining in Old Town Key West, consistently earning accolades for its exquisite “Contemporary American Cuisine.” Here, the culinary team masterfully blends the freshest local seafood, prime meats, and seasonal produce with classic preparations and inventive flair, resulting in dishes that are both sophisticated and comforting. The intimate, elegant ambiance, complete with hand-painted trompe l’oeil walls and warm lighting, creates the perfect setting for a memorable evening, whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply savoring the island’s unique flavors. From the freshly baked breads to the meticulously crafted desserts, every detail at Café Marquesa contributes to an exceptional and truly “homespun” fine dining experience.
700 Waddell Ave
Key West, FL 33040
(305) 294-1061.
Louie’s Backyard
Perched directly on the Atlantic Ocean, Louie’s Backyard offers a quintessential Key West dining experience, blending upscale cuisine with a captivating, relaxed atmosphere. Housed in a historic conch house, this beloved institution provides diners with breathtaking oceanfront views, especially renowned for its sunset vistas. The menu celebrates fresh, local seafood and creative Caribbean-American flavors, thoughtfully crafted to highlight the island’s bounty. Whether you’re indulging in a fine dining experience on the main deck or enjoying more casual fare and cocktails at the lively Afterdeck Bar, Louie’s Backyard effortlessly combines culinary excellence with the laid-back charm of the Florida Keys, making every visit a memorable occasion.
921 Truman Ave
Key West, FL 33040
(305) 296-2777
Seven Fish
Tucked away off the main bustle of Duval Street, Seven Fish offers a beloved local experience, celebrating fresh seafood with a creative and unpretentious flair. This charming bistro has built a reputation over two decades for its commitment to simple, good food, where daily catches are transformed into dishes bursting with flavor. Whether you’re savoring their renowned Thai Curry Snapper, enjoying a perfectly prepared fresh fish, or exploring other innovative options, Seven Fish consistently delivers a memorable and delicious meal in a relaxed, inviting setting that feels like a true Key West classic.
900 Catherine St
Key West, FL 33040
(305) 296-4184
El Siboney Restaurant
For an authentic and unpretentious taste of Cuba in Key West, look no further than El Siboney Restaurant. This beloved, family-owned establishment has been a local favorite for decades, consistently serving up generous portions of classic Cuban comfort food in a casual, bustling atmosphere. From their succulent roast pork and flavorful Vaca Frita to hearty Ropa Vieja and the perfect Cuban sandwich, every dish is prepared with traditional recipes that transport you straight to the streets of Havana. It’s the kind of place where locals gather, families share meals, and visitors discover the true, delicious essence of Key West’s vibrant Cuban heritage.
511 Greene St
Key West, FL 33040
(305) 916-5530
Sandbar Sports Grill
(AKA Pickle’s Pub)
For a lively and laid-back atmosphere perfect for catching a game or enjoying casual bites, Sandbar Sports Grill delivers on all fronts. Situated conveniently near the action of Duval Street, this popular spot offers a classic sports bar experience with a definite Key West twist. Their menu features a satisfying array of pub favorites and island-inspired dishes, from crispy wings and hearty burgers to fresh seafood options like their signature fish tacos and conch fritters. With plenty of screens to catch your favorite teams, a friendly vibe, and a full bar offering a wide selection of drinks, Sandbar Sports Grill is the ideal destination for a fun and relaxed meal after a day of exploring the island.